At 9:59 a.m., you are ready. Coffee poured, credit card located, browser open. Your favourite band is selling tickets at ten. You have followed the instructions, joined the waiting room and resisted refreshing the page, which apparently has the same consequences as touching a sacred artefact in an adventure film. At 10:00, the tickets disappear. At 10:02, they reappear elsewhere, considerably more expensive. Somewhere, a computer has had a productive morning.
The internet is becoming a place where this sort of morning is easier to arrange. Thales’s 2026 Bad Bot Report puts automated activity at more than 53 percent of web traffic in 2025. Humanity, which built the place and still pays the electricity bills, has become a minority in that particular accounting exercise.
Before we surrender the Wi-Fi password, however, some perspective helps. These figures count traffic, not inhabitants. One person can deploy software that generates thousands of requests; a million requests do not represent a million independent customers. Measurements also depend on the network, period and classification system. Imperva’s 2016 report already put the bot share at 51.8 percent. Depending on the census, humanity can apparently lose control of the internet several times without leaving its chair.
The changing capabilities matter more than the ceremonial crossing of 50 percent. HUMAN Security reported that traffic from AI agents and agentic browsers grew 7,851 percent during 2025, with some reaching account and checkout pages. An enormous growth rate does not establish an enormous market share, but it suggests movement. Software is increasingly able to browse, compare and act for us. The office intern now works at machine speed and never asks whether this meeting could have been an email.
Ticket buyers encountered automated competition long before conversational AI. In 2021, the US Federal Trade Commission alleged that three brokers had purchased more than 150,000 tickets using methods including automated buying software and fictitious accounts to evade purchase limits. The underlying business proposition was admirably simple: arrive before everybody else, acquire what they want, and charge them for having arrived after you.
A concert makes the economics unusually clear. Faster software cannot create another seat in row twelve. It can change who secures the existing seat, how much the eventual attendee pays, and who collects the difference. When allocation rewards speed and repeated attempts, computing resources become purchasing power. “First come, first served” acquires a curious meaning when one customer can come first under several hundred names.
Naturally, the proposed consumer response is to acquire a bot of one’s own. There are good reasons to do this. An assistant that monitors cancellations or handles an inaccessible booking form could save time and expand access. Cloudflare neatly observes: “There are wanted bots and there are unwanted humans.” Anyone who has queued behind a person arguing about an expired voucher will recognise the point.
Still, imagine every fan hiring an assistant to compete for the same ten thousand seats. The stadium remains the same size. Some people save hours; others may discover that ordinary participation now requires a subscription. Better agents, more accounts and more generous computing budgets could become advantages in an escalating contest. We would have invented a digital concierge class, followed almost immediately by premium digital concierges who know the bouncer.
The same allocation problem could arise wherever online booking controls something scarce: restaurant tables, campsites, appointments, limited products. The consequences vary enormously. Losing a novelty trainer is irritating; losing access to an essential appointment is another matter. A system that rewards constant monitoring effectively asks people to compete on their capacity to remain available. Automation can remove that burden for an individual while intensifying the competition for everyone.
Even the defences can become part of the comedy. The legitimate customer gets asked to identify bicycles, remember a password and locate a verification code. Somewhere behind the curtain, software is being assessed by other software. A poorly designed defence can leave us performing unpaid administrative theatre while better equipped operators find another route. The human experience becomes an obstacle course whose completion still guarantees absolutely nothing.
A fairer system would need to decide what opportunity each buyer should have. Lotteries could reduce the advantage of millisecond timing, provided duplicate entries were controlled. Purchase limits would need enforcement across accounts. Agents could act for customers without receiving extra chances simply because they can send more requests. Each approach has costs: identity checks can threaten privacy, and rigid controls can exclude legitimate users. Fairness requires more thought than adding another picture of a bus.
There is a wider bill, too. In its discussion of the internet’s second audience, Cloudflare describes how automated systems can consume publishers’ pages without delivering the human visits that support advertising and subscriptions. More activity can mean more server costs without more customers. We risk building an exceptionally busy shopping street where most visitors photograph the stock, nobody reads the newspaper, and the landlord celebrates record footfall.
The bots will not enjoy the concert. They will not sing badly, lose their voices or insist that the earlier albums were better. People will still do all that. Our booking systems should give those people a reasonable chance of getting through the door. Otherwise, the defining announcement of the automated age may be wonderfully familiar: your experience matters to us. Please remain in the queue.




No comments yet